Am I looking at a cat or a dog? gaze in the semantic variant of primary progressive aphasia is subject to excessive taxonomic capture.

Mustafa Seckin, M.-Marsel Mesulam, Joel L Voss, Wei Huang, Emily J Rogalski, Robert S Hurley

Research output: Contribution to journalArticlepeer-review

23 Scopus citations


Object naming impairments or anomias are the most frequent symptom in aphasia, and can be caused by a variety of underlying neurocognitive mechanisms. Anomia in neurodegenerative or primary progressive aphasias (PPA) often appears to be based on taxonomic blurring of word meaning: words such as “dog” and “cat” are still recognized generically as referring to animals, but are no longer conceptually differentiated from each other, leading to coordinate errors in word-object matching. This blurring is the hallmark symptom of the “semantic variant” of PPA, who invariably show focal atrophy in the left anterior temporal lobe. In this study we used eye tracking to characterize information processing online (in real time) as non-aphasic controls, semantic and nonsemantic PPA participants completed a word-to-object matching task. All participants (including controls) showed taxonomic capture of gaze, spending more time viewing foils that were from the same category as the target compared to unrelated foils, but capture was more extreme in the semantic PPA group. The semantic group showed heightened capture even on trials where they ultimately pointed to the correct target, demonstrating the superiority of eye movements over traditional testing methods in detecting subtle processing impairments. Heightened capture was primarily driven by a tendency to direct gaze back and forth, repeatedly, between a set of related foils on each trial, a behavior almost never shown by controls or non-semantic participants. This suggests semantic PPA participants were accumulating and weighing evidence for a probabilistic rather than definitive mapping between the noun and several candidate objects. Neurodegeneration in PPA thus appears to distort lexical concepts prior to extinguishing them altogether, causing uncertainty in recognition and word-object matching. PMID: 26500393, PMCID PMC4612367
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)68-81
JournalJournal of Neurolinguistics
StatePublished - Feb 2016


Dive into the research topics of 'Am I looking at a cat or a dog? gaze in the semantic variant of primary progressive aphasia is subject to excessive taxonomic capture.'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this