An autopsy-based study of diagnostic errors in geriatric and nongeriatric adult patients

K. Middleton, E. Clarke, S. Homann, B. Naughton, David B Neely, A. Repasy, P. R. Yarnold, M. Yungbluth, James R Webster Jr

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

18 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

One hundred sixty-two consecutive adults autopsies (87 of subjects over age 65 years and 75 of subjects aged 23 to 64 years) performed at a university hospital were studied retrospectively by six internists to determine (1) if diagnostic errors were quantitatively or qualitatively different between the two age groups; (2) if the underlying causes of error (divided into nine categories) were different or age related in any way between the two groups; and (3) any aspects of care that related age to clinical outcome. We found the frequency of major clinical/autopsy discrepancies to be a similar to those in previous studies (35%), but in only 7% of cases were these likely to have affected therapy/outcome. There was no difference in the frequency of major discrepancies between age groups. There were significantly more 'unexpected' minor discrepancies in the older patients, probably related to the multiplicity and complexity of their problems, but these would have affected therapy/outcome in only 1 (3%) of 37 cases. The most common causes of 136 clinical 'errors' in 151 autopsies were, in order of frequency: a diagnostic 'blind spot,' a conscious decision not to pursue a clinical finding (not a real 'error'), failure to account for a symptom or sign, atypical presentations, and inadequate follow-up of abnormal laboratory findings. There were no differences between the geriatric and adult groups in terms of frequency or cause of the errors. We conclude that (1) there is no difference in the diagnostic accuracy regarding cause of death between geriatric and nongeriatric patients in the acute hospital environment, and (2) closer attention to basic knowledge and clinical skills and a special focus on judgment and reasoning skills, utilizing autopsy findings among other things, will lead to even further improvement in clinical care at all ages.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)1809-1812
Number of pages4
JournalArchives of Internal Medicine
Volume149
Issue number8
StatePublished - Jan 1 1989

Fingerprint

Diagnostic Errors
Geriatrics
Autopsy
Age Groups
Clinical Competence
Optic Disk
Signs and Symptoms
Cause of Death
Therapeutics

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Internal Medicine

Cite this

Middleton, K. ; Clarke, E. ; Homann, S. ; Naughton, B. ; Neely, David B ; Repasy, A. ; Yarnold, P. R. ; Yungbluth, M. ; Webster Jr, James R. / An autopsy-based study of diagnostic errors in geriatric and nongeriatric adult patients. In: Archives of Internal Medicine. 1989 ; Vol. 149, No. 8. pp. 1809-1812.
@article{0623671dc81b47b3a618769cc2e1954b,
title = "An autopsy-based study of diagnostic errors in geriatric and nongeriatric adult patients",
abstract = "One hundred sixty-two consecutive adults autopsies (87 of subjects over age 65 years and 75 of subjects aged 23 to 64 years) performed at a university hospital were studied retrospectively by six internists to determine (1) if diagnostic errors were quantitatively or qualitatively different between the two age groups; (2) if the underlying causes of error (divided into nine categories) were different or age related in any way between the two groups; and (3) any aspects of care that related age to clinical outcome. We found the frequency of major clinical/autopsy discrepancies to be a similar to those in previous studies (35{\%}), but in only 7{\%} of cases were these likely to have affected therapy/outcome. There was no difference in the frequency of major discrepancies between age groups. There were significantly more 'unexpected' minor discrepancies in the older patients, probably related to the multiplicity and complexity of their problems, but these would have affected therapy/outcome in only 1 (3{\%}) of 37 cases. The most common causes of 136 clinical 'errors' in 151 autopsies were, in order of frequency: a diagnostic 'blind spot,' a conscious decision not to pursue a clinical finding (not a real 'error'), failure to account for a symptom or sign, atypical presentations, and inadequate follow-up of abnormal laboratory findings. There were no differences between the geriatric and adult groups in terms of frequency or cause of the errors. We conclude that (1) there is no difference in the diagnostic accuracy regarding cause of death between geriatric and nongeriatric patients in the acute hospital environment, and (2) closer attention to basic knowledge and clinical skills and a special focus on judgment and reasoning skills, utilizing autopsy findings among other things, will lead to even further improvement in clinical care at all ages.",
author = "K. Middleton and E. Clarke and S. Homann and B. Naughton and Neely, {David B} and A. Repasy and Yarnold, {P. R.} and M. Yungbluth and {Webster Jr}, {James R}",
year = "1989",
month = "1",
day = "1",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "149",
pages = "1809--1812",
journal = "JAMA Internal Medicine",
issn = "2168-6106",
publisher = "American Medical Association",
number = "8",

}

Middleton, K, Clarke, E, Homann, S, Naughton, B, Neely, DB, Repasy, A, Yarnold, PR, Yungbluth, M & Webster Jr, JR 1989, 'An autopsy-based study of diagnostic errors in geriatric and nongeriatric adult patients', Archives of Internal Medicine, vol. 149, no. 8, pp. 1809-1812.

An autopsy-based study of diagnostic errors in geriatric and nongeriatric adult patients. / Middleton, K.; Clarke, E.; Homann, S.; Naughton, B.; Neely, David B; Repasy, A.; Yarnold, P. R.; Yungbluth, M.; Webster Jr, James R.

In: Archives of Internal Medicine, Vol. 149, No. 8, 01.01.1989, p. 1809-1812.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - An autopsy-based study of diagnostic errors in geriatric and nongeriatric adult patients

AU - Middleton, K.

AU - Clarke, E.

AU - Homann, S.

AU - Naughton, B.

AU - Neely, David B

AU - Repasy, A.

AU - Yarnold, P. R.

AU - Yungbluth, M.

AU - Webster Jr, James R

PY - 1989/1/1

Y1 - 1989/1/1

N2 - One hundred sixty-two consecutive adults autopsies (87 of subjects over age 65 years and 75 of subjects aged 23 to 64 years) performed at a university hospital were studied retrospectively by six internists to determine (1) if diagnostic errors were quantitatively or qualitatively different between the two age groups; (2) if the underlying causes of error (divided into nine categories) were different or age related in any way between the two groups; and (3) any aspects of care that related age to clinical outcome. We found the frequency of major clinical/autopsy discrepancies to be a similar to those in previous studies (35%), but in only 7% of cases were these likely to have affected therapy/outcome. There was no difference in the frequency of major discrepancies between age groups. There were significantly more 'unexpected' minor discrepancies in the older patients, probably related to the multiplicity and complexity of their problems, but these would have affected therapy/outcome in only 1 (3%) of 37 cases. The most common causes of 136 clinical 'errors' in 151 autopsies were, in order of frequency: a diagnostic 'blind spot,' a conscious decision not to pursue a clinical finding (not a real 'error'), failure to account for a symptom or sign, atypical presentations, and inadequate follow-up of abnormal laboratory findings. There were no differences between the geriatric and adult groups in terms of frequency or cause of the errors. We conclude that (1) there is no difference in the diagnostic accuracy regarding cause of death between geriatric and nongeriatric patients in the acute hospital environment, and (2) closer attention to basic knowledge and clinical skills and a special focus on judgment and reasoning skills, utilizing autopsy findings among other things, will lead to even further improvement in clinical care at all ages.

AB - One hundred sixty-two consecutive adults autopsies (87 of subjects over age 65 years and 75 of subjects aged 23 to 64 years) performed at a university hospital were studied retrospectively by six internists to determine (1) if diagnostic errors were quantitatively or qualitatively different between the two age groups; (2) if the underlying causes of error (divided into nine categories) were different or age related in any way between the two groups; and (3) any aspects of care that related age to clinical outcome. We found the frequency of major clinical/autopsy discrepancies to be a similar to those in previous studies (35%), but in only 7% of cases were these likely to have affected therapy/outcome. There was no difference in the frequency of major discrepancies between age groups. There were significantly more 'unexpected' minor discrepancies in the older patients, probably related to the multiplicity and complexity of their problems, but these would have affected therapy/outcome in only 1 (3%) of 37 cases. The most common causes of 136 clinical 'errors' in 151 autopsies were, in order of frequency: a diagnostic 'blind spot,' a conscious decision not to pursue a clinical finding (not a real 'error'), failure to account for a symptom or sign, atypical presentations, and inadequate follow-up of abnormal laboratory findings. There were no differences between the geriatric and adult groups in terms of frequency or cause of the errors. We conclude that (1) there is no difference in the diagnostic accuracy regarding cause of death between geriatric and nongeriatric patients in the acute hospital environment, and (2) closer attention to basic knowledge and clinical skills and a special focus on judgment and reasoning skills, utilizing autopsy findings among other things, will lead to even further improvement in clinical care at all ages.

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0024340493&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=0024340493&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Article

C2 - 2764653

AN - SCOPUS:0024340493

VL - 149

SP - 1809

EP - 1812

JO - JAMA Internal Medicine

JF - JAMA Internal Medicine

SN - 2168-6106

IS - 8

ER -

Middleton K, Clarke E, Homann S, Naughton B, Neely DB, Repasy A et al. An autopsy-based study of diagnostic errors in geriatric and nongeriatric adult patients. Archives of Internal Medicine. 1989 Jan 1;149(8):1809-1812.