Hearing differences in Hartley guinea pig stocks from two breeders

Donna S Whitlon, Hunter Young, Mark Barna, Frédéric Depreux, Claus-Peter Richter

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Across the world, dozens of outbred Hartley guinea pig stocks are used for auditory experiments. The genetic makeup of these different stocks will differ due to differences in breeding protocols, history and genetic drift. In fact, outbred breeding protocols are not intended to produce genetically identical animals, neither across breeders, nor across time. For this reason, it is unclear how reproducible experimental results are likely to be using animals from different stocks. We evaluated the consistency of cochlear function using both clicks and tones in Hartley guinea pigs as a function of breeder (Kuiper and Charles River) and sex using archival Auditory Brain Stem Response (ABR) data and tissue from our own laboratory. Sound levels required to reach baseline threshold for click-induced ABRs were similar between male Charles River and male Kuiper guinea pig stocks. However, the median and average thresholds after exposure to high level noise were larger in the Kuiper population than in the Charles River population with corresponding threshold shifts higher in the Kuiper than in the Charles River animals. We evaluated the relationship between pure-tone thresholds and sex, age, breeder stock, left or right cochleas, weight and 5 test frequencies before and after noise exposure using a linear mixed statistical model. Across all frequencies, the effect of breeder on baseline threshold is statistically significant, with effect sizes most pronounced at the lower frequencies before exposure to noise. After noise exposure, the differences are minimal in the model, indicating that differences in threshold shift are chiefly due to differences in initial baseline hearing. However, a contingency calculation comparing response/no response at the highest speaker output at 32 kHz gave a statistically significant difference between the stocks: 28% of Kuiper cochleas responded to the highest output of the speaker as compared with 71.4% of Charles River cochleas, indicating that noise exposure induced a larger threshold shift in a greater proportion of Kuiper animals. Using our archival cochlear tissue from these studies, we confirmed the sex of each animal by PCR, then compared males and females of the Kuiper stock. Across all baseline frequencies, the effect of sex on threshold is statistically significant, with no noticeable difference after exposure. The effect sizes for baseline thresholds are most pronounced at lower frequencies. These data demonstrate that Hartley guinea pig stocks from different breeders are not uniform in their auditory characteristics, and that due to these differences, results and conclusions can differ among laboratories. Moreover, within a single stock, males and females can provide different data, confirming that male and female animals must be individually evaluated in any auditory protocol.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)69-78
Number of pages10
JournalHearing research
Volume379
DOIs
StatePublished - Aug 1 2019

Fingerprint

Cochlea
Hearing
Guinea Pigs
Rivers
Noise
Breeding
Genetic Drift
Brain Stem Auditory Evoked Potentials
Statistical Models
Population
History
Weights and Measures
Polymerase Chain Reaction

Keywords

  • ABR
  • Guinea pig
  • Hearing
  • Linear mixed model
  • Noise-induced threshold shifts
  • Outbred
  • Sex

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Sensory Systems

Cite this

Whitlon, Donna S ; Young, Hunter ; Barna, Mark ; Depreux, Frédéric ; Richter, Claus-Peter. / Hearing differences in Hartley guinea pig stocks from two breeders. In: Hearing research. 2019 ; Vol. 379. pp. 69-78.
@article{5e07ce791ea0429998a3b0bc58aecbfb,
title = "Hearing differences in Hartley guinea pig stocks from two breeders",
abstract = "Across the world, dozens of outbred Hartley guinea pig stocks are used for auditory experiments. The genetic makeup of these different stocks will differ due to differences in breeding protocols, history and genetic drift. In fact, outbred breeding protocols are not intended to produce genetically identical animals, neither across breeders, nor across time. For this reason, it is unclear how reproducible experimental results are likely to be using animals from different stocks. We evaluated the consistency of cochlear function using both clicks and tones in Hartley guinea pigs as a function of breeder (Kuiper and Charles River) and sex using archival Auditory Brain Stem Response (ABR) data and tissue from our own laboratory. Sound levels required to reach baseline threshold for click-induced ABRs were similar between male Charles River and male Kuiper guinea pig stocks. However, the median and average thresholds after exposure to high level noise were larger in the Kuiper population than in the Charles River population with corresponding threshold shifts higher in the Kuiper than in the Charles River animals. We evaluated the relationship between pure-tone thresholds and sex, age, breeder stock, left or right cochleas, weight and 5 test frequencies before and after noise exposure using a linear mixed statistical model. Across all frequencies, the effect of breeder on baseline threshold is statistically significant, with effect sizes most pronounced at the lower frequencies before exposure to noise. After noise exposure, the differences are minimal in the model, indicating that differences in threshold shift are chiefly due to differences in initial baseline hearing. However, a contingency calculation comparing response/no response at the highest speaker output at 32 kHz gave a statistically significant difference between the stocks: 28{\%} of Kuiper cochleas responded to the highest output of the speaker as compared with 71.4{\%} of Charles River cochleas, indicating that noise exposure induced a larger threshold shift in a greater proportion of Kuiper animals. Using our archival cochlear tissue from these studies, we confirmed the sex of each animal by PCR, then compared males and females of the Kuiper stock. Across all baseline frequencies, the effect of sex on threshold is statistically significant, with no noticeable difference after exposure. The effect sizes for baseline thresholds are most pronounced at lower frequencies. These data demonstrate that Hartley guinea pig stocks from different breeders are not uniform in their auditory characteristics, and that due to these differences, results and conclusions can differ among laboratories. Moreover, within a single stock, males and females can provide different data, confirming that male and female animals must be individually evaluated in any auditory protocol.",
keywords = "ABR, Guinea pig, Hearing, Linear mixed model, Noise-induced threshold shifts, Outbred, Sex",
author = "Whitlon, {Donna S} and Hunter Young and Mark Barna and Fr{\'e}d{\'e}ric Depreux and Claus-Peter Richter",
year = "2019",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.heares.2019.04.016",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "379",
pages = "69--78",
journal = "Hearing Research",
issn = "0378-5955",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Hearing differences in Hartley guinea pig stocks from two breeders. / Whitlon, Donna S; Young, Hunter; Barna, Mark; Depreux, Frédéric; Richter, Claus-Peter.

In: Hearing research, Vol. 379, 01.08.2019, p. 69-78.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Hearing differences in Hartley guinea pig stocks from two breeders

AU - Whitlon, Donna S

AU - Young, Hunter

AU - Barna, Mark

AU - Depreux, Frédéric

AU - Richter, Claus-Peter

PY - 2019/8/1

Y1 - 2019/8/1

N2 - Across the world, dozens of outbred Hartley guinea pig stocks are used for auditory experiments. The genetic makeup of these different stocks will differ due to differences in breeding protocols, history and genetic drift. In fact, outbred breeding protocols are not intended to produce genetically identical animals, neither across breeders, nor across time. For this reason, it is unclear how reproducible experimental results are likely to be using animals from different stocks. We evaluated the consistency of cochlear function using both clicks and tones in Hartley guinea pigs as a function of breeder (Kuiper and Charles River) and sex using archival Auditory Brain Stem Response (ABR) data and tissue from our own laboratory. Sound levels required to reach baseline threshold for click-induced ABRs were similar between male Charles River and male Kuiper guinea pig stocks. However, the median and average thresholds after exposure to high level noise were larger in the Kuiper population than in the Charles River population with corresponding threshold shifts higher in the Kuiper than in the Charles River animals. We evaluated the relationship between pure-tone thresholds and sex, age, breeder stock, left or right cochleas, weight and 5 test frequencies before and after noise exposure using a linear mixed statistical model. Across all frequencies, the effect of breeder on baseline threshold is statistically significant, with effect sizes most pronounced at the lower frequencies before exposure to noise. After noise exposure, the differences are minimal in the model, indicating that differences in threshold shift are chiefly due to differences in initial baseline hearing. However, a contingency calculation comparing response/no response at the highest speaker output at 32 kHz gave a statistically significant difference between the stocks: 28% of Kuiper cochleas responded to the highest output of the speaker as compared with 71.4% of Charles River cochleas, indicating that noise exposure induced a larger threshold shift in a greater proportion of Kuiper animals. Using our archival cochlear tissue from these studies, we confirmed the sex of each animal by PCR, then compared males and females of the Kuiper stock. Across all baseline frequencies, the effect of sex on threshold is statistically significant, with no noticeable difference after exposure. The effect sizes for baseline thresholds are most pronounced at lower frequencies. These data demonstrate that Hartley guinea pig stocks from different breeders are not uniform in their auditory characteristics, and that due to these differences, results and conclusions can differ among laboratories. Moreover, within a single stock, males and females can provide different data, confirming that male and female animals must be individually evaluated in any auditory protocol.

AB - Across the world, dozens of outbred Hartley guinea pig stocks are used for auditory experiments. The genetic makeup of these different stocks will differ due to differences in breeding protocols, history and genetic drift. In fact, outbred breeding protocols are not intended to produce genetically identical animals, neither across breeders, nor across time. For this reason, it is unclear how reproducible experimental results are likely to be using animals from different stocks. We evaluated the consistency of cochlear function using both clicks and tones in Hartley guinea pigs as a function of breeder (Kuiper and Charles River) and sex using archival Auditory Brain Stem Response (ABR) data and tissue from our own laboratory. Sound levels required to reach baseline threshold for click-induced ABRs were similar between male Charles River and male Kuiper guinea pig stocks. However, the median and average thresholds after exposure to high level noise were larger in the Kuiper population than in the Charles River population with corresponding threshold shifts higher in the Kuiper than in the Charles River animals. We evaluated the relationship between pure-tone thresholds and sex, age, breeder stock, left or right cochleas, weight and 5 test frequencies before and after noise exposure using a linear mixed statistical model. Across all frequencies, the effect of breeder on baseline threshold is statistically significant, with effect sizes most pronounced at the lower frequencies before exposure to noise. After noise exposure, the differences are minimal in the model, indicating that differences in threshold shift are chiefly due to differences in initial baseline hearing. However, a contingency calculation comparing response/no response at the highest speaker output at 32 kHz gave a statistically significant difference between the stocks: 28% of Kuiper cochleas responded to the highest output of the speaker as compared with 71.4% of Charles River cochleas, indicating that noise exposure induced a larger threshold shift in a greater proportion of Kuiper animals. Using our archival cochlear tissue from these studies, we confirmed the sex of each animal by PCR, then compared males and females of the Kuiper stock. Across all baseline frequencies, the effect of sex on threshold is statistically significant, with no noticeable difference after exposure. The effect sizes for baseline thresholds are most pronounced at lower frequencies. These data demonstrate that Hartley guinea pig stocks from different breeders are not uniform in their auditory characteristics, and that due to these differences, results and conclusions can differ among laboratories. Moreover, within a single stock, males and females can provide different data, confirming that male and female animals must be individually evaluated in any auditory protocol.

KW - ABR

KW - Guinea pig

KW - Hearing

KW - Linear mixed model

KW - Noise-induced threshold shifts

KW - Outbred

KW - Sex

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85065615903&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85065615903&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.heares.2019.04.016

DO - 10.1016/j.heares.2019.04.016

M3 - Article

VL - 379

SP - 69

EP - 78

JO - Hearing Research

JF - Hearing Research

SN - 0378-5955

ER -