Abstract
IMPORTANCE: Because of the similarity in clinical outcomes after elective open and endovascular repair of abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA), cost may be an important factor in choosing a procedure. OBJECTIVE: To compare total and AAA-related use of health care services, costs, and cost-effectiveness between groups randomized to open or endovascular repair. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This unblinded randomized clinical trial enrolled 881 patients undergoing planned elective repair of AAA who were candidates for open and endovascular repair procedures. Patients were randomized from October 15, 2002, to April 15, 2008, at 42 Veterans Affairs medical centers. Follow-up was completed on October 15, 2011, and data were analyzed from April 15, 2013, to April 15, 2016, based on intention to treat. MAINOUTCOMES ANDMEASURES: Mean total and AAA-related health care cost per life-year and per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY). RESULTS: A total of 881 patients (876 men [99.4%]; 5 women [0.6%]; mean [SD] age, 70 [7.8] years) were included in the analysis. After a mean of 5.2 years of follow-up, mean life-years were 4.89in the endovascular group and 4.84 in the open repair group (P =.68), and mean QALYs were 3.72 in the endovascular group and 3.70 in the open repair group (P =.82). Total mean health care costs did not differ significantly between the 2 groups (endovascular group, $142 745; open repair group, $153 533; difference, -$10 788; 95% CI, -$29 796 to $5825; P =.25). Costs related to AAA, including the initial repair, constituted nearly 40% of total costs and did not differ significantly between the 2 groups (endovascular group, $57 501; open repair group, $57 893; difference, -$393; 95% CI, -$12 071 to $7928; P =.94). Lower costs due to shorter hospitalization for initial endovascular repair were offset by increased costs from AAA-related secondary procedures and imaging studies. The probability of endovascular repair being less costly and more effective was 56.8% when effectiveness was measured in life-years and 55.4% when effectiveness was measured in QALYs for total costs and 31.3% and 34.3%, respectively, for AAA-related costs. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this multicenter randomized clinical trial with follow-up to 9 years, survival, quality of life, costs, and cost-effectiveness did not differ between elective open and endovascular repair of AAA.
Original language | English (US) |
---|---|
Pages (from-to) | 1139-1144 |
Number of pages | 6 |
Journal | JAMA surgery |
Volume | 151 |
Issue number | 12 |
DOIs | |
State | Published - Dec 1 2016 |
ASJC Scopus subject areas
- Surgery
Access to Document
Other files and links
Fingerprint
Dive into the research topics of 'Long-term cost-effectiveness in the veterans affairs open vs endovascular repair study of aortic abdominal aneurysm: A randomized clinical trial'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.Cite this
- APA
- Author
- BIBTEX
- Harvard
- Standard
- RIS
- Vancouver
}
In: JAMA surgery, Vol. 151, No. 12, 01.12.2016, p. 1139-1144.
Research output: Contribution to journal › Article › peer-review
TY - JOUR
T1 - Long-term cost-effectiveness in the veterans affairs open vs endovascular repair study of aortic abdominal aneurysm
T2 - A randomized clinical trial
AU - Lederle, Frank A.
AU - Stroupe, Kevin T.
AU - Kyriakides, Tassos C.
AU - Ge, Ling
AU - Freischlag, Julie A.
AU - Ketteler, Erika R.
AU - Kingsley, Darra D.
AU - Marek, John M.
AU - Massen, Richard J.
AU - Matteson, Brian D.
AU - David Pitcher, J.
AU - Langsfeld, Mark
AU - Corson, John D.
AU - Goff, James M.
AU - Kasirajan, Karthnik
AU - Paap, Christina
AU - Robertson, Diane C.
AU - Salam, Atef
AU - Veeraswamy, Ravi
AU - Milner, Ross
AU - Kasirajan, Karthikeshwar
AU - Guidot, Jane
AU - Lal, Brajesh K.
AU - Busuttil, Steven J.
AU - Lilly, Michael P.
AU - Braganza, Melita
AU - Ellis, Kea
AU - Patterson, Mark A.
AU - Jordan, William D.
AU - Whitley, David
AU - Taylor, Steve
AU - Passman, Marc
AU - Kerns, Donna
AU - Inman, Cindy
AU - Poirier, Jennifer
AU - Ebaugh, James
AU - Raffetto, Joseph
AU - Chew, David
AU - Lathi, Subhash
AU - Owens, Christopher
AU - Hickson, Kathleen
AU - Dosluoglu, Hasan H.
AU - Eschberger, Karen
AU - Kibbe, Melina R.
AU - Baraniewski, Henry M.
AU - Matsumura, Jon
AU - Endo, Michelle
AU - Busman, Anna
AU - Meadows, Wendy
AU - Evans, Mary
AU - Giglia, Joseph S.
AU - El Sayed, Hosam
AU - Reed, Amy B.
AU - Ruf, Madeline
AU - Ross, Stephanie
AU - Jean-Claude, Jessie M.
AU - Pinault, Gilles
AU - Kang, Preet
AU - White, Nadine
AU - Eiseman, Matthew
AU - Jones, Reba
AU - Timaran, Carlos H.
AU - Gregory Modrall, J.
AU - Burress Welborn, M.
AU - Lopez, Jorge
AU - Nguyen, Tammy
AU - Chacko, John K Y
AU - Granke, Kenneth
AU - Vouyouka, Angela G.
AU - Olgren, Erin
AU - Chand, Prakash
AU - Allende, Brenda
AU - Ranella, Michael
AU - Yales, Claudia
AU - Whitehill, Thomas A.
AU - Krupski, William C.
AU - Nehler, Mark R.
AU - Johnson, Stephen P.
AU - Jones, Darrell N.
AU - Strecker, Pamela
AU - Bhola, Michelle A.
AU - Shortell, Cynthia K.
AU - Gray, John L.
AU - Lawson, Jeffrey H.
AU - McCann, Richard
AU - Sebastian, Mark W.
AU - Tetterton, Jean Kistler
AU - Blackwell, Carla
AU - Prinzo, Patricia A.
AU - Lee, Nina
AU - Padberg, Frank T.
AU - Cerveira, Joaquim J.
AU - Zickler, Robert W.
AU - Hauck, Karen A.
AU - Berceli, Scott A.
AU - Anthony Lee, W.
AU - Keith Ozaki, C.
AU - Nelson, Peter R.
AU - Irwin, Anne S.
AU - Baum, Randy
AU - Aulivola, Bernadette
AU - Rodriguez, Heron
AU - Littooy, Fred N.
AU - Greisler, Howard
AU - O'Sullivan, Mary T.
AU - Kougias, Panagiotis
AU - Lin, Peter H.
AU - Bush, Ruth L.
AU - Guinn, Gene
AU - Bechara, Carlos
AU - Cagiannos, Catherine
AU - Pisimisis, George
AU - Barshes, Neal
AU - Pillack, Sherilyn
AU - Guillory, Barbara
AU - Cikrit, Dolores
AU - Lalka, Stephen G.
AU - Lemmon, Gary
AU - Nachreiner, Ryan
AU - Rusomaroff, Mitzi
AU - O'Brien, Elaine
AU - Cullen, Joseph J.
AU - Hoballah, Jamal
AU - John Sharp, W.
AU - McCandless, Jeanne L.
AU - Beach, Vickie
AU - Minion, David
AU - Schwarcz, Thomas H.
AU - Kimbrough, Joy
AU - Ashe, Laura
AU - Rockich, Anna
AU - Warner-Carpenter, Jill
AU - Moursi, Mohammed
AU - Eidt, John F.
AU - Brock, Sandra
AU - Bianchi, Christian
AU - Bishop, Vicki
AU - Gordon, Ian L.
AU - Fujitani, Roy
AU - Kubaska, Stephen M.
AU - Behdad, Mina
AU - Azadegan, Reza
AU - Maagas, Christine
AU - Zalecki, Kathy
AU - Hoch, John R.
AU - Carr, Sandra C.
AU - Acher, Charles
AU - Schwarze, Margaret
AU - Tefera, Girma
AU - Mell, Matthew
AU - Dunlap, Beth
AU - Rieder, Janice
AU - Stuart, John M.
AU - Weiman, Darryl S.
AU - Abul-Khoudoud, Omran
AU - Edward Garrett, H.
AU - Walsh, Sandra M.
AU - Wilson, Karen L.
AU - Seabrook, Gary R.
AU - Cambria, Robert A.
AU - Brown, Kellie R.
AU - Lewis, Brian D.
AU - Framberg, Susan
AU - Kallio, Christa
AU - Barke, Roderick A.
AU - Santilli, Steven M.
AU - D'Audiffret, Alexandre C.
AU - Oberle, Nancy
AU - Proebstle, Catherine
AU - Johnson, Lauri Lee
AU - Jacobowitz, Glenn R.
AU - Cayne, Neal
AU - Rockman, Caron
AU - Adelman, Mark
AU - Gagne, Paul
AU - Nalbandian, Matthew
AU - Caropolo, Leah J.
AU - Pipinos, Iraklis I.
AU - Johanning, Jason
AU - Lynch, Thomas
AU - De Spiegelaere, Holly
AU - Purviance, Georgia
AU - Zhou, Wei
AU - Dalman, Ronald
AU - Lee, Jason T.
AU - Safadi, Bassem
AU - Coogan, Sheila M.
AU - Wren, Sherry M.
AU - Bahmani, Doghdoo D.
AU - Maples, Deanna
AU - Thunen, Shawna
AU - Golden, Michael A.
AU - Mitchell, Marc E.
AU - Fairman, Ronald
AU - Reinhardt, Sally
AU - Wilson, Mark A.
AU - Tzeng, Edith
AU - Muluk, Satish
AU - Peterson, Nina M.
AU - Foster, Maria
AU - Edwards, James
AU - Moneta, Gregory L.
AU - Landry, Gregory
AU - Taylor, Lloyd
AU - Yeager, Richard
AU - Cannady, Eleanor
AU - Treiman, Gerald
AU - Hatton-Ward, Stephanie
AU - Salabsky, Barbara
AU - Kansal, Nikhil
AU - Owens, Erik
AU - Estes, Melanie
AU - Forbes, Beth A.
AU - Sobotta, Cinda
AU - Rapp, Joseph H.
AU - Reilly, Linda M.
AU - Perez, Sandra L.
AU - Yan, Kimberly
AU - Sarkar, Rajaabrata
AU - Dwyer, Shelley S.
AU - Chong, Karen
AU - Kohler, Ted R.
AU - Hatsukami, Thomas S.
AU - Glickerman, David G.
AU - Sobel, Michael
AU - Burdick, Thomas S.
AU - Pedersen, Kimberly
AU - Cleary, Patricia
AU - Back, Martin
AU - Bandyk, Dennis
AU - Johnson, Brad
AU - Shames, Murray
AU - Reinhard, Rebecca L.
AU - Thomas, Sandra C.
AU - Hunter, Glenn C.
AU - Leon, Luis R.
AU - Westerband, Alex
AU - Guerra, Robert J.
AU - Riveros, Macario
AU - Mills, John L.
AU - Hughes, John D.
AU - Escalante, Andrea M.
AU - Psalms, Shemuel B.
AU - Day, Nancy N.
AU - Macsata, Robyn
AU - Sidawy, Anton
AU - Weiswasser, Jonathan
AU - Arora, Subodh
AU - Jasper, Brenda J.
AU - Dardik, Alan
AU - Gahtan, Vivian
AU - Muhs, Bart E.
AU - Sumpio, Bauer E.
AU - Gusberg, Richard J.
AU - Spector, Marcelo
AU - Pollak, Jeffrey
AU - Aruny, John
AU - Lynne Kelly, E.
AU - Wong, James
AU - Vasilas, Penny
AU - Joncas, Carmelene
AU - Gelabert, Hugh A.
AU - De Virgillio, Christian
AU - Rigberg, David A.
AU - Cole, Loretta
AU - Latts, Elizabeth
AU - Swanson, Kathleen M.
AU - Johnson, Gary R.
AU - Guarino, Peter
AU - Peduzzi, Peter
AU - Antonelli, Margaret
AU - Cushing, Cindy
AU - Davis, Elizabeth
AU - Durant, Lynn
AU - Joyner, Shirley
AU - Kossack, Alice
AU - Le Gwin, Mary
AU - McBride, Vanessa
AU - O'Connor, Terry
AU - Poulton, June
AU - Stratton, Susan
AU - Zellner, Scott
AU - Snodgrass, Amanda J.
AU - Thornton, Julie
AU - Haakenson, Clair M.
AU - Jonk, Yvonne
AU - Hallett, John W.
AU - Hertzer, Norman
AU - Towne, Jonathan
AU - Katz, David A.
AU - Karrison, Theodore
AU - Matts, John P.
AU - Marottoli, Richard
AU - Kasl, Stanislav
AU - Mehta, Rajni
AU - Feldman, Richard
AU - Farrell, William
AU - Allore, Heather
AU - Perry, Edward
AU - Niederman, James
AU - Randall, Sister Frances
AU - Zeman, Reverend Michael
AU - Beckwith, Donald
AU - O'Leary, Timothy J.
AU - Huang, Grant D.
AU - Bader, Marilyn
N1 - Publisher Copyright: Copyright 2016 American Medical Association. All rights reserved.
PY - 2016/12/1
Y1 - 2016/12/1
N2 - IMPORTANCE: Because of the similarity in clinical outcomes after elective open and endovascular repair of abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA), cost may be an important factor in choosing a procedure. OBJECTIVE: To compare total and AAA-related use of health care services, costs, and cost-effectiveness between groups randomized to open or endovascular repair. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This unblinded randomized clinical trial enrolled 881 patients undergoing planned elective repair of AAA who were candidates for open and endovascular repair procedures. Patients were randomized from October 15, 2002, to April 15, 2008, at 42 Veterans Affairs medical centers. Follow-up was completed on October 15, 2011, and data were analyzed from April 15, 2013, to April 15, 2016, based on intention to treat. MAINOUTCOMES ANDMEASURES: Mean total and AAA-related health care cost per life-year and per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY). RESULTS: A total of 881 patients (876 men [99.4%]; 5 women [0.6%]; mean [SD] age, 70 [7.8] years) were included in the analysis. After a mean of 5.2 years of follow-up, mean life-years were 4.89in the endovascular group and 4.84 in the open repair group (P =.68), and mean QALYs were 3.72 in the endovascular group and 3.70 in the open repair group (P =.82). Total mean health care costs did not differ significantly between the 2 groups (endovascular group, $142 745; open repair group, $153 533; difference, -$10 788; 95% CI, -$29 796 to $5825; P =.25). Costs related to AAA, including the initial repair, constituted nearly 40% of total costs and did not differ significantly between the 2 groups (endovascular group, $57 501; open repair group, $57 893; difference, -$393; 95% CI, -$12 071 to $7928; P =.94). Lower costs due to shorter hospitalization for initial endovascular repair were offset by increased costs from AAA-related secondary procedures and imaging studies. The probability of endovascular repair being less costly and more effective was 56.8% when effectiveness was measured in life-years and 55.4% when effectiveness was measured in QALYs for total costs and 31.3% and 34.3%, respectively, for AAA-related costs. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this multicenter randomized clinical trial with follow-up to 9 years, survival, quality of life, costs, and cost-effectiveness did not differ between elective open and endovascular repair of AAA.
AB - IMPORTANCE: Because of the similarity in clinical outcomes after elective open and endovascular repair of abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA), cost may be an important factor in choosing a procedure. OBJECTIVE: To compare total and AAA-related use of health care services, costs, and cost-effectiveness between groups randomized to open or endovascular repair. DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: This unblinded randomized clinical trial enrolled 881 patients undergoing planned elective repair of AAA who were candidates for open and endovascular repair procedures. Patients were randomized from October 15, 2002, to April 15, 2008, at 42 Veterans Affairs medical centers. Follow-up was completed on October 15, 2011, and data were analyzed from April 15, 2013, to April 15, 2016, based on intention to treat. MAINOUTCOMES ANDMEASURES: Mean total and AAA-related health care cost per life-year and per quality-adjusted life-year (QALY). RESULTS: A total of 881 patients (876 men [99.4%]; 5 women [0.6%]; mean [SD] age, 70 [7.8] years) were included in the analysis. After a mean of 5.2 years of follow-up, mean life-years were 4.89in the endovascular group and 4.84 in the open repair group (P =.68), and mean QALYs were 3.72 in the endovascular group and 3.70 in the open repair group (P =.82). Total mean health care costs did not differ significantly between the 2 groups (endovascular group, $142 745; open repair group, $153 533; difference, -$10 788; 95% CI, -$29 796 to $5825; P =.25). Costs related to AAA, including the initial repair, constituted nearly 40% of total costs and did not differ significantly between the 2 groups (endovascular group, $57 501; open repair group, $57 893; difference, -$393; 95% CI, -$12 071 to $7928; P =.94). Lower costs due to shorter hospitalization for initial endovascular repair were offset by increased costs from AAA-related secondary procedures and imaging studies. The probability of endovascular repair being less costly and more effective was 56.8% when effectiveness was measured in life-years and 55.4% when effectiveness was measured in QALYs for total costs and 31.3% and 34.3%, respectively, for AAA-related costs. CONCLUSIONS AND RELEVANCE: In this multicenter randomized clinical trial with follow-up to 9 years, survival, quality of life, costs, and cost-effectiveness did not differ between elective open and endovascular repair of AAA.
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85011408066&partnerID=8YFLogxK
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=85011408066&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1001/jamasurg.2016.2783
DO - 10.1001/jamasurg.2016.2783
M3 - Article
C2 - 27627802
AN - SCOPUS:85011408066
SN - 2168-6254
VL - 151
SP - 1139
EP - 1144
JO - JAMA surgery
JF - JAMA surgery
IS - 12
ER -