One Supreme Court: Supremacy, Inferiority, and the Judicial Department of the United States

James E. Pfander*

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Book/ReportBook

24 Scopus citations


Despite over two hundred years of experience with constitutional government, much remains unclear about the power of the political branches to curtail or re-define the judicial power of the United States. Uncertainty persists about the basis on which state courts and federal agencies may hear federal claims and the degree to which federal courts must review their decisions. Scholars approach these questions from a range of vantage points and have arrived at widely varying conclusions about the relationship between congressional and judicial power. Deploying familiar forms of legal analysis, and relying upon a new account of the Court's supremacy in relation to lower courts and tribunals, this book advances a departmental conception of the judiciary. It argues that Congress can enlist the state courts, lower federal courts, and administrative agencies to hear federal claims in the first instance, but all of these tribunals must operate within a hierarchical framework over which the "one supreme Court" identified in the Constitution exercises ultimate supervisory authority. This book takes up such important debates in the federal courts' literature as Congress's power to strip the federal courts of jurisdiction to review state court decisions, its authority to assign decision-making authority to state courts and non-Article III tribunals, its control over the doctrine of vertical stare decisis, and its ability to craft rules of practice for the federal system.

Original languageEnglish (US)
PublisherOxford University Press
Number of pages328
ISBN (Electronic)9780199867233
ISBN (Print)9780195340334
StatePublished - Sep 1 2009


  • Federal courts
  • Federal system
  • Legal analysis
  • Non-article iii tribunals
  • State court decisions
  • Vertical stare decisis

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • General Social Sciences


Dive into the research topics of 'One Supreme Court: Supremacy, Inferiority, and the Judicial Department of the United States'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.

Cite this