Reducing protein oxidation in low-flow electrospray enables deeper investigation of proteoforms by top down proteomics

Kyunggon Kim, Philip D Compton, Timothy K. Toby, Paul Martin Thomas, John T Wilkins, R Kannan Mutharasan, Neil L Kelleher*

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

5 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Enabling the implementation of top down proteomic techniques within clinical workflows requires a dramatic increase in sensitivity. It has been previously demonstrated that electrospray ionization (ESI) becomes more efficient with decreasing volumetric flow rates at the emitter. Therefore, narrow inner diameter (I.D.) columns used in front-end chromatographic separations yield increased sensitivity. However, the smaller cross-sectional area of a narrow I.D. column places a larger fraction of the eluent in fluid communication with the electrode within the high voltage union that facilitates electrospray ionization (ESI), leading to increased oxidation of solution-phase proteins. Oxidation of proteins alters their chemical state of the protein, complicates data analysis, and reduces the depth of proteome coverage attained in a typical top-down proteomics experiment. Excessive protein oxidation results in poor deconvolution and exact mass calculations from MS1 spectra, interferes with peak isolation for MS/MS fragmentation, and effectively reduces sensitivity by splitting ion current. All of these factors deteriorate top down mass spectral data quality, an effect that becomes more pronounced as column diameter decreases. Artificial protein oxidation can also mislead investigations of in vivo protein oxidation. All of these effects are accentuated in comparison to bottom up proteomics due to the increased probability of having oxidizable residues within a particular species with increasing mass. Herein, we describe a configuration (which we term "Low Protein Oxidation (LPOx)") for proteomics experiments created by re-arranging liquid chromatography (LC) plumbing and present its application to artificial protein oxidation and show a marked improvement in detection sensitivity. Using a standard mixture of five intact proteins, we demonstrate that the LPOx configuration reduces protein oxidation up to 90% using 50. μm I.D. columns when compared to a conventional LC plumbing configuration with 50. μm I.D. column. As a proof-of-concept study, at least 11 distinct proteoforms of serum Apolipoprotein A1 were detected with the LPOx configuration. This innovative LC configuration can be applied to the top down identification and characterization of proteoforms obscured by abundant artificial protein oxidation at low flowrates, all while using reduced amounts of valuable protein samples.

Original languageEnglish (US)
Pages (from-to)40-47
Number of pages8
JournalEuPA Open Proteomics
Volume8
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 1 2015

Fingerprint

Proteomics
Oxidation
Proteins
Liquid chromatography
Sanitary Engineering
Liquid Chromatography
Plumbing
Electrospray ionization
Workflow
Apolipoprotein A-I
Deconvolution
Proteome
Electrodes
Experiments
Flow rate
Ions

Keywords

  • Electrospray ionization
  • Protein oxidation
  • Proteoforms
  • Top down

ASJC Scopus subject areas

  • Biochemistry

Cite this

@article{f795a0e7ee4342d89b31b6933c8cbd5d,
title = "Reducing protein oxidation in low-flow electrospray enables deeper investigation of proteoforms by top down proteomics",
abstract = "Enabling the implementation of top down proteomic techniques within clinical workflows requires a dramatic increase in sensitivity. It has been previously demonstrated that electrospray ionization (ESI) becomes more efficient with decreasing volumetric flow rates at the emitter. Therefore, narrow inner diameter (I.D.) columns used in front-end chromatographic separations yield increased sensitivity. However, the smaller cross-sectional area of a narrow I.D. column places a larger fraction of the eluent in fluid communication with the electrode within the high voltage union that facilitates electrospray ionization (ESI), leading to increased oxidation of solution-phase proteins. Oxidation of proteins alters their chemical state of the protein, complicates data analysis, and reduces the depth of proteome coverage attained in a typical top-down proteomics experiment. Excessive protein oxidation results in poor deconvolution and exact mass calculations from MS1 spectra, interferes with peak isolation for MS/MS fragmentation, and effectively reduces sensitivity by splitting ion current. All of these factors deteriorate top down mass spectral data quality, an effect that becomes more pronounced as column diameter decreases. Artificial protein oxidation can also mislead investigations of in vivo protein oxidation. All of these effects are accentuated in comparison to bottom up proteomics due to the increased probability of having oxidizable residues within a particular species with increasing mass. Herein, we describe a configuration (which we term {"}Low Protein Oxidation (LPOx){"}) for proteomics experiments created by re-arranging liquid chromatography (LC) plumbing and present its application to artificial protein oxidation and show a marked improvement in detection sensitivity. Using a standard mixture of five intact proteins, we demonstrate that the LPOx configuration reduces protein oxidation up to 90{\%} using 50. μm I.D. columns when compared to a conventional LC plumbing configuration with 50. μm I.D. column. As a proof-of-concept study, at least 11 distinct proteoforms of serum Apolipoprotein A1 were detected with the LPOx configuration. This innovative LC configuration can be applied to the top down identification and characterization of proteoforms obscured by abundant artificial protein oxidation at low flowrates, all while using reduced amounts of valuable protein samples.",
keywords = "Electrospray ionization, Protein oxidation, Proteoforms, Top down",
author = "Kyunggon Kim and Compton, {Philip D} and Toby, {Timothy K.} and Thomas, {Paul Martin} and Wilkins, {John T} and Mutharasan, {R Kannan} and Kelleher, {Neil L}",
year = "2015",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.euprot.2015.05.005",
language = "English (US)",
volume = "8",
pages = "40--47",
journal = "EuPA Open Proteomics",
issn = "2212-9685",
publisher = "Elsevier BV",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Reducing protein oxidation in low-flow electrospray enables deeper investigation of proteoforms by top down proteomics

AU - Kim, Kyunggon

AU - Compton, Philip D

AU - Toby, Timothy K.

AU - Thomas, Paul Martin

AU - Wilkins, John T

AU - Mutharasan, R Kannan

AU - Kelleher, Neil L

PY - 2015/9/1

Y1 - 2015/9/1

N2 - Enabling the implementation of top down proteomic techniques within clinical workflows requires a dramatic increase in sensitivity. It has been previously demonstrated that electrospray ionization (ESI) becomes more efficient with decreasing volumetric flow rates at the emitter. Therefore, narrow inner diameter (I.D.) columns used in front-end chromatographic separations yield increased sensitivity. However, the smaller cross-sectional area of a narrow I.D. column places a larger fraction of the eluent in fluid communication with the electrode within the high voltage union that facilitates electrospray ionization (ESI), leading to increased oxidation of solution-phase proteins. Oxidation of proteins alters their chemical state of the protein, complicates data analysis, and reduces the depth of proteome coverage attained in a typical top-down proteomics experiment. Excessive protein oxidation results in poor deconvolution and exact mass calculations from MS1 spectra, interferes with peak isolation for MS/MS fragmentation, and effectively reduces sensitivity by splitting ion current. All of these factors deteriorate top down mass spectral data quality, an effect that becomes more pronounced as column diameter decreases. Artificial protein oxidation can also mislead investigations of in vivo protein oxidation. All of these effects are accentuated in comparison to bottom up proteomics due to the increased probability of having oxidizable residues within a particular species with increasing mass. Herein, we describe a configuration (which we term "Low Protein Oxidation (LPOx)") for proteomics experiments created by re-arranging liquid chromatography (LC) plumbing and present its application to artificial protein oxidation and show a marked improvement in detection sensitivity. Using a standard mixture of five intact proteins, we demonstrate that the LPOx configuration reduces protein oxidation up to 90% using 50. μm I.D. columns when compared to a conventional LC plumbing configuration with 50. μm I.D. column. As a proof-of-concept study, at least 11 distinct proteoforms of serum Apolipoprotein A1 were detected with the LPOx configuration. This innovative LC configuration can be applied to the top down identification and characterization of proteoforms obscured by abundant artificial protein oxidation at low flowrates, all while using reduced amounts of valuable protein samples.

AB - Enabling the implementation of top down proteomic techniques within clinical workflows requires a dramatic increase in sensitivity. It has been previously demonstrated that electrospray ionization (ESI) becomes more efficient with decreasing volumetric flow rates at the emitter. Therefore, narrow inner diameter (I.D.) columns used in front-end chromatographic separations yield increased sensitivity. However, the smaller cross-sectional area of a narrow I.D. column places a larger fraction of the eluent in fluid communication with the electrode within the high voltage union that facilitates electrospray ionization (ESI), leading to increased oxidation of solution-phase proteins. Oxidation of proteins alters their chemical state of the protein, complicates data analysis, and reduces the depth of proteome coverage attained in a typical top-down proteomics experiment. Excessive protein oxidation results in poor deconvolution and exact mass calculations from MS1 spectra, interferes with peak isolation for MS/MS fragmentation, and effectively reduces sensitivity by splitting ion current. All of these factors deteriorate top down mass spectral data quality, an effect that becomes more pronounced as column diameter decreases. Artificial protein oxidation can also mislead investigations of in vivo protein oxidation. All of these effects are accentuated in comparison to bottom up proteomics due to the increased probability of having oxidizable residues within a particular species with increasing mass. Herein, we describe a configuration (which we term "Low Protein Oxidation (LPOx)") for proteomics experiments created by re-arranging liquid chromatography (LC) plumbing and present its application to artificial protein oxidation and show a marked improvement in detection sensitivity. Using a standard mixture of five intact proteins, we demonstrate that the LPOx configuration reduces protein oxidation up to 90% using 50. μm I.D. columns when compared to a conventional LC plumbing configuration with 50. μm I.D. column. As a proof-of-concept study, at least 11 distinct proteoforms of serum Apolipoprotein A1 were detected with the LPOx configuration. This innovative LC configuration can be applied to the top down identification and characterization of proteoforms obscured by abundant artificial protein oxidation at low flowrates, all while using reduced amounts of valuable protein samples.

KW - Electrospray ionization

KW - Protein oxidation

KW - Proteoforms

KW - Top down

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84940962857&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/citedby.url?scp=84940962857&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1016/j.euprot.2015.05.005

DO - 10.1016/j.euprot.2015.05.005

M3 - Article

VL - 8

SP - 40

EP - 47

JO - EuPA Open Proteomics

JF - EuPA Open Proteomics

SN - 2212-9685

ER -